Vaccine Failure, Market Expectations and Inflated Valuations

For the last year and a half the biggest sentiment driver in markets has undoutedly been COVID-19. This is perfectly reasonable as the virus is probably the biggest single driver of variables that matter in financial markets – from inflation expectations to earnings. Yet it has been striking that most financial analysts have been outsourcing their analysis of the trajectory of the virus to those in public health.

In theory this is reasonable. Many are assuming that the public health experts are, well, experts. And since financial analysts are not experts in epidemiology, deferring to those that are is a rational course to take. Yet if this pandemic has made one thing crystal clear it is that the public health experts are far from infallible.

This seems to be coming to a head this week. This week at least three major newspapers are throwing in the towel and admitting that the vaccine is not nearly effective enough to get the virus under control. The Financial Times runs the headline “Are vaccines becoming less effective at preventing Covid infection?”; the New York Times has “Israel, Once the Model for Beating Covid, Faces New Surge of Infections”; while The Times of London has “Double Covid vaccine doesn’t stop symptoms for half of Delta cases”.

The problem here for markets is simple enough: reflation and solid earnings growth was thought to be coming because the vaccine would return things to normal. Now that this looks unlikely, it is difficult to provide an alternative rational for reflation and solid earnings growth.

Are the markets waking up to this? Maybe. UK gilt yields have been tracking hospitalisations and in recent days they have ticked up.

Inflation expectations took a dip too, although they later reversed.

It seems fair to say that markets are currently attempting to process the facts as they come in. There is no way they are at the point where they are accepting widespread failure of the vaccination program, but they are starting to feel out this possibility.

This isn’t just a question of interest to traders either. Investors should pay close attention too. Stock market valuations have gone truly nuts on what we must assume are very inflated future earnings growth expectations. The Shiller CAPE is at it’s second highest point in history.

Tobin’s Q has gone totally gangbusters, now exceeding any previous peak.

Q Ratio

These are markets priced for perfection. Yet as we enter autumn/winter with a vaccine that is not keeping to the promises made on its behalf, we could be facing down another wave of the virus. This will then spur debate about more interventions that will impact the economy and with it earnings.


About pilkingtonphil

Philip Pilkington is a macroeconomist and investment professional. Writing about all things macro and investment. Views my own.You can follow him on Twitter at @philippilk.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Vaccine Failure, Market Expectations and Inflated Valuations

  1. skippy says:

    Hay Phil … I can’t help but look at such graphs without putting things into context like computational power, advent of day traders due to it, and furthermore full immersion media – positive/negative, and lastly narrow academic institutionalization via funding and culling [sad to see what has transpired over the last few years]. On top of all that one has to consider governments picking winners and losers during the neoliberal period, and all that portends [networks], and now a bloody virus has stuck a spanner in the narrative.

    Then due to the nature of a shift in work/private activities we have a massive redeployment of capital/loan flows to behaviors which have completely blindsided the market, per se with demand for timber in extension/renovating to repurpose primary residences, yet in some cases the trees are still more valuable in the ground as a carbon offset investment, all acerbated by previous ownership consolidation and financially tweaked to its limit – as one example.

    Yet I still ponder all the flows in the undersea cables as contracts in an almost Roubini mannerism with the machinations of Mfg/logistics, decades in the making, unable to contend with a known historical occurrence due to the dominate ideology of this period.

    I tilt my Tottori too you ….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s